INTRO
I’m still striving to write shorter, but more frequent posts. Increasing job duties and life in an on-going pandemic make this difficult. I also wanted to reiterate that having some understanding of dialectical materialism will make my scholarship more understandable going forward. I posted some resources in my study guide for those who would like suggestions on where to start learning about diamat. It is virtually impossible to explain dialectics succinctly in these blog posts, but I’ve found this quote from Marx a good reminder: “There is no royal road to science, and only those who do not dread the fatiguing climb of its steep paths have a chance of gaining its luminous summits.”
PRODUCTION <—> CONSUMPTION
I just want to emphasize what may seem obvious to some, but may also be easy for many to miss. In the production-consumption contradiction, at least under capitalism, production is the principal aspect. Production and consumption are both intimately linked and exert mutual influence, but production does so in a more dominant way. Deciding what is produced, how it is produced, where and how the results are distributed constitutes power. Those who control the means of production primarily determine what is consumed. The consumer, by and large, doesn’t decide what is produced, where, when, etc. Try forcing McDonalds to make a certain product. It’s not possible. The corporation may ask for “customer feedback,” but that’s an example of power being in the hands of the producer. We vastly overestimate consumer power and influence at the risk of underestimating the producers’—which in capitalist society is concentrated in relatively few hands.[1]
This misunderstanding of the production-consumption dialectic is rooted in liberalism, which emphasizes individualism. Liberalism is the political ideology undergirding capitalism and is the basis of neoclassical or mainstream economic theory. Mainstream media conditions us not to think of ourselves as developing human beings, but as consumers. Mainstream economics is full of talk about being “rational consumers” where we are assumed to be informed shoppers in markets where buyers and sellers meet on an equal playing field. This economic theory emphasizes markets, prices, supply and demand, shopping, and mystifies the power held by producers. And this is all connected to liberalism. Liberalism, which passes as common sense in the u.s., is all about individualism. Your individuality. Your individual rights. Your property. So, it translates well to neoclassical economics, which emphasizes individual choice. We are conditioned to believe that we solve our ills via individual choice. Improve your health by buying healthier food; make sure to vote in the “most important election in our lifetimes”; don’t forget to recycle; and make sure to purchase an electric vehicle![2]
How does this relate to scholarly communication? You might see where my argument is headed. We’re bound to fail if we view open access and scholcomm in terms of individual choice. “I made my paper OA.” “They ‘chose’ to keep theirs behind a paywall.” “He can’t afford an APC, and she chose a diamond journal.” Etc. etc. We’re not going to individual choice our way to a more just world or a socialist future. We can only do that through organization and a radical reconfiguration of who owns and controls the means of production. Scholarly research is an incredibly social activity, but the wealth it produces is held by relatively few people. The University shows no interest in radically transforming this arrangement. Lenin, defining the state, remarked: “According to Marx, the state is an organ of class rule, an organ for the oppression of one class by another; it is the creation of ‘order,’ which legalizes and perpetuates this oppression by moderating the conflict between classes.”
The Nelson Memo, the closest thing the state has offered in terms of a band aid to the contradictions in scholarly publishing, is rooted in (neo)liberalism and neoclassical economic thought. It ignores larger questions of distribution of wealth and power, instead, and targets individuals. It’s disappointing how easy it is to miss the fact that the Nelson Memo doesn’t make demands of corporations, but instead targets workers! The Memo will prove to be woefully inadequate for the issues at hand. Scholarly researchers, who don’t own nor control any significant means of production, are treated as the problem needing fixing[3]. We, as individuals, are told to deposit our work in the correct repository. Don’t pay attention to the fact that capital is primarily responsible for the problems we face. Mandates that target individuals create new contradictions mostly centered on surveillance, compliance, auditing, and punishment. I wrote about this two years ago. A major contradiction in liberalism is between “freedom” and discipline/punishment. The Nelson Memo amplifies the latter aspect of the contradiction. Some members of the publishing oligopoly immediately praised the Nelson Memo, as it didn’t directly regulate them. An outsider observing things could conclude that individual researchers are the root of the problem as they are now mandated to “fix” it.
I wanted to keep this short, but I feel like I barely scratched the surface in ~900 words. That’s all to say: the production<—>consumption contradiction is worth using in our analysis as it could lead to insight not otherwise gained using non-dialectical frameworks.
You can support my writing and research by sharing this post and buying me a coffee 😊
Subscribe to get notified of future posts.
My recent blog posts include:
- Eight Theses on Scholarly Communication
- Transformative Zombies
- Open, Power, and the Organized Masses
[1] Did we ask for ChatGPT or generative AI or was it unleashed on us by its producers?
[2] See Jared Ball’s “The Myth and Propaganda of Black Buying Power” for a breakdown on the fallacy of individual “purchasing power”
[3] Editing a journal doesn’t constitute control within publishing as a sphere of economic activity. See this post for more on how editors are coerced to serve the demands of capital